"Once a scout, always a scout," they say. Unless, of course, you're gay.
(I noticed the rhyme, briefly considered writing this as a poem so that I could rename this post "
Lamentation of a Former Boy Scout", which has a much better ring to it, but then decided I can't write poetry.)
I started early in the
Scouts. I don't think I was ever a Tiger, but I was definitely a Cub Scout. My mom was a Den Leader. Once I was a Boy Scout I went to summer camp on
Catalina Island. I learned first aid and how to tie knots and how to avoid blisters when hiking. My Cub Scout den still gets together periodically.
I became over-involved in extracurriculars during high school, so I talked it over with my parents during my freshman year and decided that Scouts would be the thing to drop. I took about two years off, and then my old scout leader started an Explorer group for boys and girls together. It was all the fun parts of scouting (camping, canoe trips down the Colorado River,
Jamborees) without the stupid merit badges or pressure to advance in rank. It was basically a subsidized, well-organized social group.
But then somebody pointed out that I was only a few
merit badges away from being an
Eagle Scout. I didn't have the time to do it, but it seemed pretty stupid not to just finish it up and have that extra line on my resume. So I stayed up a lot of late nights and got it done. My Eagle Scout Project was actually a lot of fun. My parents were off in Rome the weekend I did it (which they still deeply regret), so I got all sorts of neighborhood people together, invited all my favorite friends, and we did a bunch of manual labor. It was great! Seriously! To this day, it's still cool to drive past the site and be able to say "I built that!"
If any of you have ever been to an Eagle Scout Ceremony, it's usually an extra 15 minutes tacked onto the end of a normal weekly scout meeting, maybe with some punch

and cookies afterward, and your whole family comes. But no, not me. My mom went crazy. It was a lot like a wedding, in fact. There were about 250 people there (including numerous family members who'd flown in from all parts of the country to surprise me). A live band played the national anthem. The Mayor delivered a poem he'd written about me, and on behalf of the city council declared that day "Matt _____ Day" in my city, with a gold-leafed proclamation and everything. Representatives of my Congressman and Senators spoke (one of whom presented me with a flag that had been flown over the U.S. Capitol building in my honor). My mom even arranged to have a live
bald eagle there, but it unexpectedly died just a few days before the ceremony. Oh yeah, and everybody brought a gift. I made out like a bandit.
Before and after that event, I traveled the world with the Scouts (at one point appearing on live TV being broadcast to 100 million people), and served as a merit badge counselor to younger scouts. I went on innumerable hikes, camping trips, and other adventures. I shot off model rockets and climbed rocks, and made a lot of friends.
So, needless to say, Scouting was pretty important in my life. I was never gung-ho in the traditional sense (I have totally forgotten how to tie most knots, and couldn't start a fire without a match to save my life). But I did it in my own way, and I had a lot of fun. I always planned to be a volunteer leader as I got older, because I thought the organization had so much potential to make a difference in the lives of boys.
I have ultra-progressive friends who would projectile vomit if they heard me say anything to intimate that gender matters, but I do think it's important for boys to be mentored by older boys and men. I think it's good to take boys away from the society of women every now and then. I was never a very rough-and-tumble kid, and I often got a little homesick. But there's something to be said for getting dirty, learning to cuss, learning to take shit from older boys, winning and losing at tug-of-war, and swimming a mile in the cold Pacific Ocean.
I think the Boy Scouts is excellent at teaching a boy to feel self-sufficient. In modern Los Angeles, I'm almost positive I'll never need to tie a tourniquet or build a shelter out of found materials or use a compass to navigate. But if a 13 year old boy can be made to feel as though he could survive if he had to, that he's not totally dependent on 911 and supermarkets and mom's minivan, he will grow up to be a more confident, self-sufficient man. If he learns at 12 to take a joke from a 16 year old without crying to his mom for protection, he'll be able to stand up for himself at work and in politics. If he is made to improvise a skit in front of a campfire, he'll learn that he can be creative and funny. If he learns the value of being "trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean and reverent", even if he doesn't always hold to those ideals, he will be a better person. (If you were wondering, yes, I just recited the Scout Law from memory.)
Even when I was young, I realized that Scouting wasn't as helpful for me as it was for others, because I had a family who taught me a lot of these things. But there were kids in my troop whose lives were transformed. I'm thinking of one kid in particular who was being raised by his mom and grandma. He was about as effeminate as a person with a penis can be. Long, delicate fingers with long manicured nails. Perfectly white skin from never going outside. Plenty of baby fat he never worked off. He spoke with the long, nasally vowels of an aristocrat (even though he wasn't one). He was the precious baby boy of two doting women with nothing else in their lives, and was weak. He was in junior high and still had no clue how to do anything for himself. People instinctively disliked him because he was a pushover. And he took a lot of shit in the Scouts. But he also got his first sunburn. He learned that his soft hands were capable of chopping wood and putting up a tent. He learned that his
assmar didn't prevent him from hiking to the top of a mountain. He learned that when he stopped saying condescending things to other boys and just participated, the boys had no problem with him. He made friends, earned respect and built confidence. In short, over the course of 6 years, he became a man before our eyes. I saw him recently, working at REI as an expert in rock climbing and other outdoor sports. Gee, where do you think he developed his passion for the outdoors?
And then there's
Dale. Boy Scouts v. Dale is a Supreme Court case that upheld the right of the Scouts to exclude gays and atheists from the scouting movement. If you're interested in the legal acrobatics, you can read that link. But it's not really about the law. Actually, I agree with the outcome of the case, as far as it goes. Private organizations should have the right to discriminate however they want, as long as they're not subsidized or supported by the government. If I'm having a dinner party for some gay friends, the government should not be able to force me to invite two homophobic straight guys who also want to come. It's my house, it's my private event, and it's none of the government's business. However, if I'm holding my party at a public school, or if I get a tax break when I purchase the food, that's another story. (Of course, the Scouts ARE subsidized and supported by the government, but I'll leave that for another day).
But having the right to do something doesn't make the doing of it right. The organization claims that part of its mission is to uphold the virtues of heterosexuality and religiosity, so they shouldn't have to invite homos or atheists to their dinner party. Insofar as that's true, they'd be within the letter of the law. But I don't believe that really is (and if it is, it shouldn't be) the mission of the organization. The point is to make men out of boys. It's to teach valuable lessons and inculcate worthwhile virtues.
I just don't believe gay or atheist boys are incapable or undeserving of the lessons that Scouting provides. If anything, they need them more because they're going to face a lot of crap in the adult world that straight people and Bible-beaters don't. They need to be self-sufficient and confident. And I don't think gay men or atheists are incapable of teaching those lessons or passing on those virtues. I am just as much of a man as I was when I became an Eagle Scout. In fact, I feel like I embody that Scout Law a lot more than I did when I was in the closet.
I'm not exactly sure why the Scouts is so anti-gay. The Mormon church officially adopted the Boy Scouts of America as a church youth program, so their control over the organization goes a long way to explain the anti-gay policies. But I think there's still that stereotype that gay = pedophile, and pedophile + 11 to 18 year old boys + skinny dipping in a mountain lake = guaranteed sexual abuse in the tents after the campfire is doused. I'm sure it goes without saying that that's offensive and absurd. The Scouts screens potential leaders, just as any youth organization should.
So that's why I call myself a "former" Eagle Scout. It's not the terminology I'm supposed to use. You don't "earn" the rank of Eagle. You "become" an Eagle. But I'm ashamed of the organization. I will not be putting it on my resume, because by so doing I proclaim that I believe what they believe. And I will not proclaim that discrimination against gay teenagers is acceptable. Until they want the whole me, I don't want them. And I've told them so. Backed up by the Supreme Court and the Mormon Church, I'm not hopeful that things will ever change. And that makes me sad. It could be so good for so many people.
Labels: controversy, disappointment, discrimination, fun activities, government, law, male bonding, morality, opinion, politics, religion